River Adur Kayaking, Gilda Radner Last Words, Warhammer 40k Dreadnought Datasheet, Can A Fuse Work Intermittently, Articles W

Get the latest news, stats and more about Brad Wanamaker on USbasket, Washington 22bet withdrawal charges Wizards, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Austin Spurs, Maine Celtics. But unlike the defendant in Sarkis, he did not broadly solicit applications for an agent to represent him via nationwide media but instead specifically contacted LeGarie in California. Deposit Ins. He has not feuded with a superstar or failed to develop a rookie. 1995). 1991) to support a contrary conclusion is misplaced. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 12(b)(2), Rule 12(b)(2) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 23(b)(3) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 12(b)(6) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 8(a) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. The biggest differences between Las Vegas and Orlando, which hosts eight teams, are that in Orlando there are no fans and news media access is tightly controlled. The Knicks coach, Mike D'Antoni, is also represented by LeGarie. 2002). I dont know if theres any competition, LeGarie said, referring to him and Cooper. We represent totally different types of clients.. Nurse, the 2019-20 NBA Coach of the Year, missed the playoffs for the first time as an NBA head coach this season as the Raptors went just 27-45. Warren is the president of WGL Management, which represents a number of top coaches, front office personnel, and executives across the NBA. Moreover, while Nurse's employment contracts were with a Toronto team, he states in his declaration that for the past five years he has been a resident of Florida and that before that he was a resident of Texas. Confirm that your trade proposal is valid according to the NBA collective bargaining agreement. 7. rosters, but the operation is highly professional. Balistreri v. Pacifica Police Dep't, 901 F.2d 696, 699 (9th Cir. Here, Nurse entered into an ongoing contract with an agent who resides in California and did most of his work in California. When the movie producer sued Garcia Marquez in California, the Court found purposeful availment on the basis that the contract envisioned production of a film, most of the work for which would have been performed in California. Id. Anyone can read what you share. 2008)). Corp. v. Brit.-Am. LLC, No. He states in his declaration that [t]o do that [he has] to build strong relationships where we have confidence in one another[, ] which always takes time. Id. at 13-14. Compl. . The storm of pink slips set one record for the most N.B.A. LeGarie states in his declaration that he sent at least seven invoices to Nurse during the period he represented him, between 2013 and 2020. 2005)). See Long, 2016 WL 6024591, at *6 (If Defendants had not done business with Plaintiff and purposefully availed themselves of the forum state, Plaintiff would have no claims against them because he would not have suffered an injury that resulted out of the alleged breach of contract). william penn foundation family recovery fund. CGC 14 542232 in the Superior Court of California, County of San Francisco. On the other hand, in Sarkis v. Lajcak , the court held that there was no purposeful availment where the defendant advertised an open position for a Legal Counsel in The Economist, a global weekly news magazine, and the plaintiff responded to the advertisement from California, providing California contact information in his cover letter and on his resume. I really, truly like hanging out with them. All were represented by Career Sports and Entertainment, Coopers Atlanta-based agency. Dwight Jaynes simply unloads on the agent for Kevin Pritchard and Tom Penn, Warren LeGarie, going back 20 years to question some of Legarie's recent statements.He then uses that to put the current . Compl. The second factor weighs in favor of Plaintiffs. Sometimes those highs and lows come in rapid succession. Decl. Therefore, the Court concludes the anticipated future consequences of the agreement between Nurse and LeGarie were aimed at the forum. iii. Ive chosen to be that way. Id. Jul 2004 - Present18 years 8 months. . Nurse states in his declaration that he believes that LeGarie was in Costa Rica when Nurse spoke with him. Warren LeGarie is President at WGL management where he represents a number of top coaches, front office personnel, and executives across the. Brian Colangelo, the President and General Manager of the Raptors at the time, watched the Vipers play and invited Nurse to fly to Toronto to meet with the Raptors' front office about potentially joining as an assistant coach. The stakes for the coaches are also much higher. Nurse states further that he has never owned property in California, been employed in California, maintained an office in California, or conducted business in California. Id. Powered by phpBB Forum Software phpBB Limited. That included coaching the Raptors to the first NBA championship in franchise history in 2019. Richmond Techs., Inc. v. Aumtech Bus. More than 100,000 fans attended last years 11-day schedule in Las Vegas, and LeGarie and Hall expect 120,000 to 130,000 this year. Mahoney v. Bank of Am., Nat. See, e.g., Dahon N. 1995). Astronomical player salaries and the rise of powerful player agents created some of those pressures. For the first time, Cooper also has a serious rival in the business Warren LeGarie, a San Francisco-based agent who represents seven current coaches, two dozen assistants and several front-office . Courts have held that 1391 does not require that a majority of the events have occurred in the district where the suit is filed, nor does it require that the events in that district predominate.' These facts also undercut his argument that exercising jurisdiction over him in California would give rise to a conflict of sovereignty between California and Canada. LeGaries growing stable of coaches includes Mike DAntoni of the Knicks, Rick Carlisle of the Mavericks, Mike Brown of the Cavaliers and Mike Dunleavy of the Clippers. Wgl Management is located at 1108 Masonic Ave in San Francisco, California 94117. The purpose of a motion to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6) is to test the legal sufficiency of the complaint. N. Star Int'l v. Ariz. Corp. Comm'n, 720 F.2d 578, 581 (9th Cir. Over 23 years, dozens of Coopers clients fired, dismissed, replaced, terminated or, in the sanitized parlance of news releases, relieved of his duties. Still, it hurts every time. It said, Were trying to get our foot in the door.. There is sufficient evidence, however, to establish that a substantial part of the events or omissions that gave rise to Plaintiffs' claims occurred in this district under Section 1391(b)(2). From left, Sam Mitchell (Raptors), Randy Wittman (Timberwolves), and P. J. Carlesimo (Thunder) lost their jobs before Christmas. The man behind the Vegas mid-summer classic is sports agent Warren LeGarie. "The Vegas Take" with "Sharp and Shapiro" is a daily radio show brought to you live from Las Vegas from 6PM - 8PM, Monday through Friday, on 101.5 FM/720 AM . 1391(b), a civil action may be brought in: 1) a judicial district in which any defendant resides, if all defendants are residents of the State in which the district is located; 2) a judicial district in which a substantial part of the events or omissions giving rise to the claim occurred, or a substantial part of property that is the subject of the action is situated; or 3) if there is no district in which an action may otherwise be brought as provided in this section, any judicial district in which any defendant is subject to the court's personal jurisdiction with respect to such action. The plaintiff bears the burden of showing that venue is proper. Nurse contends this test is not met because Plaintiffs' claims arise out of conduct that occurred in Canada and not California. Nick Nurse has settled a lawsuit filed against him by his former agent Warren LeGarie, according to court documents. basketball. In 1986, coaches earned an average of $200,000, and no one used an agent. . 16; LeGarie Decl. He had maintained a checking account, not his principal one, in Los Angeles since 1988 for the purposes of having an account in dollars for certain transactions occurring outside of California. Id. A civil lawsuit has been filed against Toronto Raptors head coach Nick Nurse by former agent Warren LeGarie for breach of contract. It was his vision, armed with a wealth of long time professional basketball relationships and numerous, well worn summer league experiences that helped bring the Summer League to Las Vegas, Read More. In contract disputes, courts have looked to such factors as where the contract was negotiated or executed, where it was to be performed, and where the alleged breach occurred.' Both say they are selective in choosing clients and have no intention of building a monopoly. They certainly can empathize with the sting of seeing ones client fired. The fact that Nurse contacted LeGarie in California by telephone during the negotiations does not support purposeful availment. Warren LeGarie: 8/19/2021: $500.00: Monetary Contribution: Steve Sisolak: 2022 Annual CE Filing: Warren LeGarie: 9/2/2021: $500.00: Monetary Contribution: Steve Sisolak: 2022 Annual CE Filing: Warren LeGarie: 3/29/2022: Monetary Contribution: Steve Sisolak: 2022 CE Report 1: Back to Search. A complaint must contain either direct or inferential allegations respecting all the material elements necessary to sustain recovery under some viable legal theory. Bell Atl. Id. These statements indicate the parties anticipated that LeGarie would represent Nurse in his negotiations with the Toronto Raptors on an ongoing basis and the oral agreement was not limited to the assistant coaching position that prompted Nurse's initial call to LeGarie. Oct. 27, 2017) (quoting Batt v. City & County of San Francisco, 155 Cal.App.4th 65, 82 (2007) (citation omitted), disapproved on other grounds by McWilliams v. City of Long Beach, 56 Cal.4th 613 (2013)). Mr. LeGarie is the president of San Francisco based WGL Management, a principal in VSL Properties, LLC and the Executive Director and co-founder of the NBA Summer League. He states that [t]he vast majority of this work was performed in California. Id. coaches represented by Lonnie Cooper have already been fired this season. They stated that checks should be made out to Warren LeGarie Management and that wire transfers may be made to a Bank of America branch located in Santa Monica, California. Says agent Warren LeGarie and him are in constant discussion. He has never been a California resident. Id. Today, the average coaching salary is about $3.5 million. Two days later, Eddie Jordan was fired by the Washington Wizards. As reported by USA Today's Jeff Zillgit, "Defendant Nurse failed to do certain things required by the representation . Rule 8(a) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure states that a pleading which sets forth a claim for relief . In today's episode of the Sports Business Classroom Audio Experience, we sat down with Warren Legarie, Co-Founder of the Las Vegas Summer League and NBA Agent. Core-Vent, 11 F.3d at 1489. Feb. 1, 2010) (holding that under California law, an accounting is generally a remedy in equity but that a request for an accounting can be alleged as a cause of action when a defendant owes a fiduciary duty to a plaintiff which requires an accounting, and that some balance is due to the plaintiff that can only be ascertained by an accounting.) (citing Teselle, 173 Cal.App.4th at 179); cf. Select the first team from the drop down menu. Id. As reported by USA Today's Jeff Zillgit, "Defendant Nurse failed to do certain things required by the representation . Civ. Per LeGarie, the agreement was that he would receive 3 percent commission on any head coaching contracts negotiated and 4 percent commission on any assistant coaching contracts negotiated. (A number of coaches used player agents until the players union began enforcing a conflict-of-interest rule that had been flouted for years.) . Last Fridays session, featuring Lonzo Balls debut with the Los Angeles Lakers, sold out in advance a first. In an event-driven town, we are that N.B.A. Thats still my baby, he said. 21 May. Mock Archives 2017 Mock Draft 2016 Mock Draft 2015 Mock Draft History Complete Draft History . Where, as here, the motion is based on written materials rather than an evidentiary hearing, the plaintiff need only make a prima facie showing of jurisdictional facts. They were a massive disappointment, yes, but also so transcendent for brief moments. In today's episode of the Sports Business Classroom Audio Experience, we sat down with Warren Legarie, Co-Founder of the Las Vegas Summer League and NBA Agent. As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. Warren Legarie Active San Francisco, CA President for Legarie Management, Inc. (415)431-7772 Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544, 562 (2007) (citing Car Carriers, Inc. v. Ford Motor Co., 745 F.2d 1101, 1106 (7th Cir. Decl.") 1. Nurse states in his declaration that following the telephone conversation LeGarie traveled to Toronto to meet with [Nurse], and he orally agreed to help [him] review the [assistant coach] contract. Nurse Decl. 377 F.3d at 407. NBA regulations prohibit agents from representing both coaches and players, so LeGarie works with the coaches while Tellem and Armstrong handle the players. DraftExpress - NBA Player Agent Warren Legarie of Agency NO AFFILIATED AGENCY and his players. And yet by mid-December, Cooper had lost six N.B.A. LeGarie and Hall are careful not to disparage their competition the much smaller summer leagues in Orlando, Fla., and Utah but it is clear they think teams that do not attend Vegas are making a poor decision, and are ceding a competitive advantage. . . Although many of the events relevant to Plaintiffs' claims occurred in Canada, significant events also occurred in this district. 942 F.2d at 619. In ruling on a motion to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6), the court analyzes the complaint and takes all allegations of material fact as true and construe[s] them in the light most favorable to the non-moving party. Parks Sch. Thus, this factor favors neither party); Joe Boxer Corp. v. R. Siskind & Co., Inc., No. Here, as in Sinatra, Nurse had an agent in the United States. . 1991) ([U]se of the mails, telephone, or other international communications simply do not qualify as purposeful activity invoking the benefits and protection of the [forum] state.) (internal quotation marks omitted). The relationship between LeGarie and Nurse began in 2013, when Nurse entered into discussions with the Toronto Raptors about the possibility of an assistant coaching position. LeGarie, a longtime player agent who shifted his focus to coaches five years ago, is a social butterfly and a consummate power broker (or broker of happiness, as LeGarie whimsically calls himself). Motion at 4-13. Hunter Pyle, quoted in the article, gave the following statement: "Warren LeGarie has successfully represented numerous . The court found that because the defendant had allowed the underlying action to proceed in the forum state he had ratified the plaintiff's choice of forum and therefore purposefully availed himself of the forum state's legal protections. If the defendant directly solicits business in the forum state, the resulting transactions will probably constitute the deliberate transaction of business invoking the benefits of the forum states laws. Decker Coal Co. v. Commonwealth Edison Co., 805 F.2d 834, 840 (9th Cir. Thus, for example, in Long, the court found that this factor favored a finding of purposeful availment based on the parties' significant continuing obligations to each other[, ] citing evidence and allegations in the complaint indicating that the parties' obligations . from $187.00 per group. The facts here appear to fall somewhere between Long and LocusPoint on the one hand and Sarkis, on the other. Dec. 2, 2011) (A number of courts have held that an accounting is merely an equitable remedy, and therefore cannot be maintained as an independent cause of action.). See Id. Although the plaintiff was a California corporation and two of the sales contracts contained a California choice of law provision - the third contained Illinois and New York choice of law provisions - the court found that there was no personal jurisdiction over the defendant in California. For the first time, Cooper also has a serious rival in the business Warren LeGarie, a San Francisco-based agent who represents seven current coaches, two dozen assistants and several front-office executives. Oops! . There was no written contract between Nurse and LeGarie. The Raptors initially were not interested but in April 2020, they contacted Nurse directly and informed him that they were ready to consider a new contract. Warren LeGarie who represents several NBA head coaches, assistant coaches and front-office executives said in his claim, "Defendant Nurse failed to do certain things required by the. I put a proposal on a size 21 shoe, said Hall, who sent it off to the New York-New York Hotel and Casino. coaches. Artec Group, Inc. v. Klimov, No. This factor requires the court to consider the burden on the defendant of litigating in the forum. Solutions, No. Check back later! at 5. Finally, the court relied on the rule that when a buyer orders goods from another state, the buyer does not purposefully avail itself of that state's laws where the seller controls the location of performance. Id. Cal. Ballard v. Savage, 65 F.3d 1495, 1500 (9th Cir. Co. of Illinois, No. summer league game on Monday between the Golden State Warriors and the Cleveland Cavaliers at Thomas and Mack Center in Las Vegas. Id. Talk to the Veterans Crisis Line now Albert Hall, left, and Warren LeGarie created the Las Vegas version of the N.B.A. Nurse points to Fujitsu-ICL Sys., Inc. v. Efmark Serv. He said analysts' criticism can have real impact. To believe that any of 2023's neo-contenders can become bonafide champs over the next few months is to believe that a once-in-a-quarter-century occurrence is about to transpire. Nothing recent. Accordingly, the Court concludes there is specific jurisdiction over Nurse in this case. "We provide a credible product," said Warren LeGarie, executive director of the N.B.A.'s Las Vegas summer league. draft, the Las Vegas summer league is the most important event on the N.B.A.s summer calendar. Duality underpins practically everything about the brief existence of the KD, Harden and Kyrie Nets. Vuori v. Grasshopper Cap. But mostly, he wondered how any of these teams could claim to have improved their prospects. Day 12: Driving at Night in Costa Rica Day 11: Arenal Volcano, Costa Rica Day 10: Leaving Corcovado National Park Day 9: Sirena Ranger Station, Corcovado Day 8: Hiking the Corcovado, Costa Rica Day 7: Drive to Pureto Jimenez, Costa Rica Day 6: Drive to Naranjo, Costa Rica The stock person found someone so I could ask my questions better in English. Legarie Management, Inc is the only company we know about that is registered to this address. After the two parties were unable to reach a resolution via arbitration in the summer, the lawsuit was scheduled to go to a jury trial in February with Nurse, LeGarie, Masai Ujiri and Bobby Webster among the parties expected to testify. I think it starts there. Co., 845 F.2d 802, 816 (9th Cir. 12. Did you make a change because the interim coach is a better coach? Half of the games are still played in Cox Pavilion, but the other half are played in the adjoining Thomas and Mack Center, capacity 17,923. Select the third team from the drop down menu. LeGarie and Albert Hall, the co-founder and current vice president for business operations for the summer league, put up $30,000 of their own money. Nurse left LeGarie to sign with Andy Miller of Klutch Sports shortly before the contract was signed. They run a junior N.B.A. Tools and Resources Used by Real General Managers. Fifteen years ago the summer landscape was splintered, the exhibition calendar was a hodgepodge and the organizations involved were fly-by-night. With respect to course of dealings, the evidence showed that the parties' communications consisted of telephone calls and faxes, which are not sufficient to establish purposeful availment; the only two times the defendant was in California for meetings, the meetings were unrelated to the claims asserted in the case. Among his current clients are Rick Carlisle of the Dallas Mavericks, Scott Brooks of the Washington Wizards, Terry Stotts and Neil Olshey of the Portland Trail Blazers and Dwane Casey of the Detroit Pistons. None of these got fired on a controversial situation, Cooper said. Nurse Decl. In evaluating whether the parties' course of dealing supports a finding of purposeful availment, courts look to whether the quality and nature of a defendant's relationship with the plaintiff can be viewed as random, fortuitous, or attenuated. LocusPoint Networks, LLC v. Warren LeGarie, the summer league founder and NBA coach agent, watches his interns on the Thomas &Mack concourse like a proud papa. C 98-4899 SI, 1999 WL 429549, * 6 (N.D. Cal. Nonetheless, the Court finds that the contacts between the parties were not random and fortuitous in light of the evidence that LeGarie conducted 90% of his work on Nurse's behalf in California, that Nurse sent payment for Plaintiffs' work to Plaintiffs' California bank at least six times, and that Nurse and Raptor executives met LeGarie in California in connection with LeGarie's representation of Nurse on numerous occasions. List of people with the surname LEGARIE. Nick Nurse has settled a lawsuit filed against him by his former agent Warren LeGarie, according to court documents. It is less clear whether Nurse purposefully availed himself of the privilege of doing business in California by soliciting business in the forum state. Plaintiffs argue that their relationship with Nurse was not random, fortuitous or attenuated, pointing to evidence that the relationship lasted seven years, that they were in regular contact during that period and that LeGarie negotiated four NBA contracts for Nurse, including a Head Coach contract that was valued at $9 million. Id. Defendant did not file a response to the supplemental declaration and the deadline to do so has now passed. D.T.V., LLC, 2014 WL 3836792, at *7 (citing Burger King, 471 U.S. at 479). Parties who reach out beyond one state and create continuing relationships and obligations with citizens of another state are subject to regulation and sanctions in the other State for the consequences of their activities. Burger King, 471 U.S. at 473. Videos Other Speakers See All Speakers Though the two men lost money the first year, by the second they were profitable. there is no applicable federal statute governing personal jurisdiction, the district court applies the law of the state in which the district court sits. Dole Food Company, Inc. v. Watts, 303 F.3d 1104, 1110 (9th Cir. It became free-to-play, [] LeGarie's company, LeGarie Management, Inc. is a California Corporation based in San Francisco and LeGarie and his company performed a significant portion of the work under the agreement with Nurse in this district. Nurse left LeGarie to sign with Andy Miller of Klutch Sports shortly before the contract was signed. 17-CV-03872-JCS, 2017 WL 4865564, at *13 (N.D. Cal. 5. Compl. Its cheaper than day care, Hall said. The reasons for their failure may have been inherent to the whole project. Both have an abundant passion for the N.B.A. A. But for that conduct, Plaintiffs' contract claims against Nurse would not have arisen. LeGarie is also seeking financial relief and commission for Nurse's contract extension. Warren Legarie Political Campaign Contributions 2008 Election Cycle. Menu. 16-CV-7067-PJH, 2017 WL 2021363, at *5 (N.D. Cal. 7. Compl. 17-CV-06362-JCS, 2018 WL 1014633, at *14 (N.D. Cal. In three seasons as the Raptors' head coach, Nurse has a 138-88 record and led Toronto to the playoffs twice. Id. Sarkis v. Lajcak, 425 Fed.Appx. A few years ago, when the Cavaliers were head- hunting for a general manager, resulting in the hiring of Danny Ferry, agent Warren LeGarie tried to pressure Nuggets owner E. Stanley Kroenke into gi Thus, under 1391, venue may be proper in multiple districts if a substantial part' of the underlying events took place in each of those districts. Id. at *4. 8(a). 10. courts have accorded this factor little weight. Id. Motion at 8-9. NBA agent Warren LeGarie, Brown's representative at WGL Management, addressed that question in an exclusive interview with The Sacramento Bee, saying Brown is prepared to accept the job if the . 5, 9; Declaration of Warren LeGarie in Support of Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendant's Motion to Dismiss ("LeGarie Decl.") 2; Supplemental Declaration of Warren LeGarie ("LeGarie Supp. The Motion is GRANTED with respect to the accounting claim (Claim Five), which is dismissed with prejudice. Australiabasket. He has engaged in coaching-related travel to California, however, including basketball games against NBA teams in California and player training sessions in Los Angeles, and attending one pro-am golf tournament. Id. Id. shall contain . at 15-16 (citing Amer v. Wells Fargo Bank NA, No. Id. Im very proud of them, that every single one walked out with their heads high and with their dignity., Agents Feel the Pain When Coaches Are Fired, https://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/28/sports/basketball/28agent.html. A showing that a defendant purposefully availed himself of the privilege of doing business in a forum state typically consists of evidence of the defendant's action in the forum, such as executing or performing a contract there. Id. Co., 355 U.S. 220, 223 (1957))). (Fourth, the forum state's interest in adjudication is a toss-up. [T]his factor seems to be a toss-up, with perhaps a slight edge going to appellees); Ting v. Orbit Communication Co., Ltd., 105 F.3d 666, 1997 WL 8470, at * 5 (9th Cir. commissioner, until he got the go-ahead to organize the Las Vegas league, heavily supported by the current commissioner, Adam Silver. General jurisdiction may be established when a defendant's contacts with a state are substantial or continuous and systematic such that the defendant can be haled into court in that state in any action, even if the action is unrelated to those contacts. Bancroft & Masters, Inc. v. Augusta Nat. 19. Rivers coached the Boston Celtics to the championship last June. Your submission has been received! Id. According to Nurse, Plaintiffs' allegations are not sufficient as to either of these requirements. When a defendant moves to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction, the plaintiff bears the burden of demonstrating that the court has jurisdiction over the defendant. Pebble Beach Co. v. Caddy, 453 F.3d 1151, 1154 (9th Cir. . 13-CV-2530-W JMA, 2014 WL 314421, at *11 (S.D. Plaintiffs contend that by contacting LeGarie to seek representation in connection with Nurse's contract negotiations with the Raptors, Nurse was soliciting business in California. 1987)((citation omitted). Id. His career began as a player agent in Europe where he represented more than 100 players per season in various professional leagues. . Advertisement He received commitments from Washington, Phoenix, Denver, Cleveland and Boston, and. 636(c). Here, the oral agreement between LeGarie and Nurse was open-ended with respect to duration, LeGarie Decl. 1990). (citation omitted). 3:14-CV-01278-JSC, 2014 WL 3836792, at *5 (N.D. Cal. coaches fired before Christmas and reminded Cooper how much the league has changed. at 15-18. Plaintiffs have supplied a declaration from Wendy Cohn, an attorney who represented Plaintiffs in pre-litigation discussions with Nurse, stating that in May 2021 she received a series of emails from Andrew Latack, Senior Vice President of Business and Legal Affairs at Klutch Sports Group (Klutch) informing her that Klutch was Nurse's agent and that correspondence for Nurse should be directed to Latack at an address in Beverly Hills, California. We have the best time.. The lawsuit says that Nurse's extension was for four years and worth $32 million in total. In evaluating the facts, the trial court must draw all reasonable inferences in favor of the non-moving party and resolve all factual conflicts in favor of the non-moving party. Id.